Episode 30 - The Verdict (1982) (Guest: John

Episode 30 - The Verdict (1982) (Guest: John "Rusty" Wing)

Jonathan Hafetz

Loading...

Media is loading
 

Description

The Verdict (1982) tells the story of down-on-his-luck Boston lawyer, Frank Galvin (Paul Newman). Galvin had been a rising star until he was framed for jury tampering by a partner at his elite Boston law firm because he planned to expose the firm's illegalities. Galvin left the firm and his marriage and career fell apart. After Galvin hits rock bottom, his former partner and friend Mickey Morrisey (Jack Warden) sends him a medical malpractice case as a favor; the case involves a botched delivery and is expected to settle out of court for a significant sum. But Galvin is moved after visiting the woman in the hospital, where he sees her in a comatose state. Galvin refuses the settlement offer and takes the case to trial, where he confronts the hospital’s high-powered and corrupt attorney Ed Concannon (James Mason) and a hostile judge (Milo O’Shea), Galvin also has a romantic relationship with another attorney, Laura Fischer (Charlotte Rampling) whom he meets in a bar but, unbeknownst to him, is a spy planted by Concannon. Galvin discovers the hospital is covering up its negligence. Although the judge excludes this evidence, Galvin wins a huge damage award as the jury sees the truth. The Verdict was directed by Sidney Lumet and written by David Mamet, adapted from Barry Reed’s 1980 novel of the same name. It is a gripping courtroom drama and a moving story of redemption. My guest is John (“Rusty”) Wing, Senior Counsel at Lankler, Siffert & Wohl, and a nationally recognized criminal defense attorney (full bio here)

Timestamps:

0.00 Introduction
3:23 A lawyer down on his luck
6:26 Jury-tampering
10:29 Rejecting a settlement offer without consulting the client
17:58 Why judges pressure settlement
26:53 Prepping the witness
32:05 The pretrial investigation
41:23 A mistrial?
44:09 The judge takes over the direct examination
47:46 A heated fight in chambers
49:57 The trial's pivotal moment
51:54 The judge’s evidentiary rulings
57:37 The summation
59:20 Jury nullification
106:23 A comparison with "12 Angry Men"

Further reading:

Bergman, Paul & Asimow, Reel Justice: The Courtroom Goes to the Movies (2006)

Mikulee, Sven, “‘The Verdict’: Sidney Lumet and David Mamet’s Masterpiece as a Blend of a Courtroom Drama and a Personal Redemption Story,” Cinephilia and Beyond

Parker, Richard D., “The Good Lawyer: The Verdict” in Screening Justice – The Cinema of Law: Significant Films of Law, Order and Social Justice (Rennard Strickland et. al. eds., 2006)

Souther, Sharon A., “The Artist’s Search for Justice in the Justice System: A Discussion of Representative Films of Sidney Lumet and Works from the World of Literature on the Law,” 25 Cardozo Arts & Ent. L.J. 687 (2007)

Valero, Geraldo, "Revisiting Sidney Lumet's The Verdict," RogerEbert.com (Aug. 15, 2023)

Publication Date

8-6-2024

Disciplines

Law

Episode 30 - The Verdict (1982) (Guest: John

Share

COinS